Explore what midas Civil can do for your projects, and what features can help for you
The latest Installs, patches and release notesCustomer Hub
Search our knowledge base, or open technical queries
Explore engineering trends, case studies, tricks, and tipsEvents
Technical seminars and webinars by bridge expertsM.E.N
A Member Board of MIDAS Engineering Network(M.E.N)
Bridge Insight : New Development in Long Span Arch Bridges
Culvert is similar to a bridge in that it is a structure that allows pedestrians and vehicles to cross obstacles, such as roads and railways. However, the terms bridge and culvert are used differently. Factors such as type of obstacle, usage, surrounding terrain, constructability, and span length are used as criteria to distinguish between culverts and bridges.
Fig. Box culvert under roadway
In accordance with the National Bridge Inspection Standards (NBIS) in the Hydraulic design of Highway Culverts of the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), span length of structures less than 20ft (6.1m) are defined as culverts. Although this criterion is not a standard that distinguishes the two structures, it is commonly used. A conceptual diagram of the FHWA standards and the geographical differences in which the culvert and bridge are installed are shown in the figure below.
Fig. Difference between culvert and bridge (according to FHWA)
Culverts are used mainly for crossing streams or for drainages. Culverts are also used to provide grade separated crossing pedestrian and bicycle traffic on roadways or railways. In this page, structures installed for crossing streams or drainages are classified as buried structures, and structures installed for pedestrian passage are classified as grade separated structures.
Buried structures are generally used for conveying water. They are used to cross streams in locations where roads or railroads pass, or for underground drainage. Since these structures are not large, they are classified as culverts rather than bridges, and structures that meet the required capacity are selected from the standard design table without detailed design.
The shape of a bridge structure should be chosen according to its application and situation. In most cases, pipe culverts or box culverts are used, but depending on the situation, precast concrete arch culverts, three-sided culverts (bottomless culvert, open bottom culvert), or long-span corrugated steel culverts are also used.
Fig. Buried rigid culverts (concrete box culvert and pipe culvert)
Since these types of structures transmit vertical loads through the structure’s capacity and soil arching action, which is one of the soil-structure interaction, there is a significant difference in the way load is transferred depending on the shape of the structure. Furthermore, the barrel (size, shape, material) and inlet configuration (pipe, end section, headwalls, wingwalls, bevels, and tapers) must be designed according to FHWA’s ‘Hydraulic design of Highway Culverts’ in order to provide adequate hydraulic capacity.
Fig. Culvert at stream crossings (under highway and railway)
An example of a structural analysis model of a box culvert, and the loads being applied is shown in the figure below.
Fig. Loads on buried box culvert
Culverts are also installed on routes through which roadways, railways, or major drainage-ways pass giving passage to pedestrian traffic or cyclist, and depending on the region, culverts also provide passage to equestrian, cattle or camels. Structures used for these purposes are classified into overpass and underpass depending on the location of the passage. Bridges are also classified into overbridges and underbridges, which have similar roles but differ in the size of the structure. Culverts can be used when they are more economical than bridges, considering both constructability and hydraulic and structural requirements. Safety and aesthetics are also important factors when considering culverts.
Fig. Culvert crosses the Major Ways (underpass and overpass)
Structures made for traffic management are generally made of three-sided culverts and have longer span lengths than structures for drainage systems. These structures are classified as long-span culverts in FHWA’s ‘Hydraulic design of Highway Culverts’, and the span length is proposed in the range of 20ft to 40ft (7m to 14m). However, recently, culverts having longer span length have been manufactured due to the development of new manufacturing methods and materials.
Fig. Long Span Culvert (‘Hydraulic design of Highway Culverts’ Figure 1.15, FHWA)
Three-sided culverts can be classified into two types: flat top and arch top. A structural analysis model and a conceptual diagram of the applied loads is shown in the figure below.
Fig. Loads on Three-Sided Culvert (Flat top)
Fig. Loads on Three-Sided Culvert (arch top)
Culverts and buried culverts used for drainage systems and waterways are clearly distinguished from bridges. However, they may not be easy to distinguish if they serve a similar role to that of bridges. Culverts and bridges have many differences, including the design method, construction method, maintenance method, etc., but some of the most important differences are as follows:
The span length, which is a common criterion for distinguishing culverts and bridges, defines what kind of obstacles the structure should cross. Bridges are structures made to cross valleys, rivers, and even seas, so their span length is inevitably long. However, culverts are structures that are installed in narrow areas, so their span length is short. When choosing between culverts or bridges, it is not possible to choose only considering the type of obstacle, but the economical, constructability, and surrounding environments must all be considered as well.
Culverts are either completely covered or bordered on both sides of the embankment material. Therefore, not only the vehicle loads, but also the weight of the soil covered on the culvert or the lateral soil pressure should also be considered in the design. The soil covering or surrounding the culvert plays an important structural role. For example, soil stability directly affects the culvert’s structural performance, while lateral soil pressure enhances the culvert’s ability to support vertical loads.
The components of culverts are simple compared to the components of bridges, which are composed of various components including superstructures (deck, girder, bearing) and substructures (pierhead, pier, pilecap, pile, abutment, etc.). Culverts can consist of only pipes or concrete boxes that can become passages like tunnels, and if necessary, wing walls or foundations are added.
Culverts, like bridges, require maintenance according to standards, but there are differences in the details. In the case of culverts installed for drainage purposes, management is necessary because the waterway may be blocked by debris and sediment. Furthermore, culverts must be managed to prevent leakage that may occur in scours and joints that occur in inlets and outlets to prevent loss of bearing capacity or undermining.
Additional differences between culverts and bridges not mentioned on this page are found in the link below.