Understanding Creep Primary & Creep Secondary

December 9, 2021

Table of Contents


1. Introduction

2. Characteristics of Creep

3. Factors Affecting Creep

4. Creep Effects

5. Conclusion


1. Introduction


A concrete specimen when subjected to load undergoes a response that is both immediate & time-dependent. The time-dependent effect can be majorly induced due to creep & shrinkage. If we talk about the deformation-induced for a specimen under sustained loading, then its value increases & can be many times greater than its initial immediate value. Therefore, it becomes essential to consider these long-term effects.


To start with, let’s understand what does creep and shrinkage stands for.


Creep: It is the effect due to which concrete undergoes continuous deformation under sustained loading applied for a considerable time.


Shrinkage: It is drying of concrete and is independent of applied loads. Since shrinkage will cause contraction in concrete, if the contraction is restrained then tensile stress gets developed. And this tensile stress can cause the cracking of concrete.


Differential creep & shrinkage: The differential creep & shrinkage exists in the composite structure.


Since the material of the girder and slab can be different, this will induce different time-dependent effects on both. But since both the parts are integrally connected, internal stresses will generate to reduce the differential effect just like eigen stresses develop in the case of temperature.


Even when the same material is used for both girder & deck, the difference in age will also cause different time-dependent effects, resulting in differential effects.


To accurately consider the effects of creep & shrinkage, two prerequisites are necessary:


  • Reliable data for the creep and shrinkage characteristics of the concrete mix; and
  • Analytical and/or numerical procedures for the inclusion of these time effects in the analysis and design of the structure.


2. Characteristics of Creep



As discussed above that under sustained stress, creep strain develops gradually with time. But the creep develops rapidly, and later the rate of increase slows appreciably with time as shown in Figure 1.


Fig 1
Figure 1. Concrete strain components under sustained load

We can infer from the figure that when the time is tending to infinity, creep would be approaching a limiting value. Hence, after several years, the rate of change of creep is quite small. Due to this reason around 50 percent of the final creep develops in the first 2–3 months and about 90 percent develops after 2–3 years.


3. Factors Affecting Creep



Concrete mix: Creep is inversely proportional to the characteristic strength of concrete. So, for a specific stress level, creep would be more in lower strength concrete.


Aggregate: An increase in aggregate content or the maximum aggregate size reduces creep.


Water-cement ratio: Creep also decreases as the water-to-cement ratio is reduced.


Environment: Creep increases as the relative humidity decreases.


Surface area: Creep is greater in thin members with large surface-area-to-volume ratios, such as slabs. However, the dependence of creep on relative humidity and the size and shape of the specimen decreases as the concrete strength increases.


Ambient temperature: A rise in temperature increases the deformability of the cement paste and accelerates drying, and thus increases creep.


Age of concrete & loading: Concrete loaded at an early age undergoes creep more than concrete loaded at a later age.


4. Creep Effects

The Creep effects can be categorized in two ways:


  1. Primary effects: Creep Primary
  2. Secondary effects: Creep Secondary


The primary effects are independent of the boundary conditions of the structure and can be calculated based on the formulations given in various design codes. While the secondary effects are dependent on the boundary conditions of the structure.


If we talk about the creep primary according to code CEB-FIP 1990, then it is assumed to be linearly related to stress & for constant stress applied at time t0, it can be calculated as:


equation 1


∅(t,t0) is the creep coefficient

Eci is the modulus of elasticity


The creep coefficient can be further calculated as:


equation 2


0 is the notional creep coefficient

βc is the coefficient to describe the development of creep after loading

t is the age of concrete (days) at the moment considered

t0 is the age of concrete at loading (days)


To understand the effects of creep we’ll be taking an example of a simply supported beam.


4.1 Creep Primary:


In this example, we’re having a simply supported beam that is loaded with an axial load of 500 kN. Self-weight is not considered for the analysis.


Fig 2Figure 2. Loading & boundary definition


The maximum axial deformation for this load is 6.847 mm:


Fig 3Figure 3. Deformation under axial load


If we check the creep coefficient for a stage duration of 7 days, where element is activated at the age of 3 days calculated from the software as per code CEB FIP 1990, the value is 0.783



Fig 4Figure 4. Creep coefficient function corresponding to 10 days


Using this value, the creep primary deformation can be calculated:


Creep Primary deformation = Creep coefficient x deformation due to sustained stress


= 0.78 x 6.84 =5.3mm


If we check the creep primary deformation for a stage duration of 7 days, where the element is activated at the age of 3 days the maximum deformation is 5.24 mm:


Fig 5Figure 5. Deformation under Creep Primary

So, the actual deformation is very close to the deformation obtained as per manual calculation wiz. 5.3mm.


So, in this way creep primary effect is considered. To understand the behavior of creep secondary, we’ll be considering the second example.


In the case of the first example, the structure deformation is not restrained, hence the creep effects will be released, and stress accumulation won’t be dominant. So, in this coming example, we’re considering an integral type of structure. First, it would be simply supported, and at a later stage, the boundary condition would be changed to fixed hence integral action will come into the picture. Once the structure is restrained, the creep effects will not be released, and stress accumulation will occur which can be seen in creep secondary results.


4.2 Creep Secondary:


In this coming example, two beams are cast having the support condition as simply supported & loading as shown.


Fig 6Figure 6. Loading & boundary definition in Stage 1


In this stage, the creep primary effects would be induced according to the member age & material used. But since the supports are simply supported, the secondary effects will not be dominant here & the values are quite insignificant:


Fig 7Figure 7. BMD due to creep secondary in Stage 1


But in the second construction stage, the integral action of the beam is simulated, and the end conditions become fixed as shown below:


Fig 8Figure 8. Changed boundary condition in Stage 2

So, here the primary effects would be in accordance with the support condition of Stage 1. But since the restrains provided now will not allow for free deformation, secondary effects will be dominant in the structure:


Fig 9Figure 9. BMD due to creep secondary in Stage 2


So, from the example above, we can clearly infer that the secondary effects are dependent on the boundary condition provided.


5. Conclusion


From the discussed examples, we can understand that why it is important to consider the time-dependent effects. We’ve seen that depending upon the boundary condition, creep secondary effects changes for the structure. If the free movement against creep is allowed, then the creep secondary effects won’t be dominant but in case there are restrain provided then these effects become quite dominant. Hence, it is quite important to consider these effects for the structure.


Kindly refer attached document for creep verification.

Subscribe S.O.S Newsletter

About the Author
Mihir Jain | Structural Engineer | Midas IT India

Mihir pursued his Masters in Structural Dynamics from IIT Roorkee. His research area includes non-linear analysis & risk-targeted seismic design. He enjoys working on different kinds of bridges & provides technical assistance for bridge-related projects.




DOWNLOAD Download the
Creep Verification Handout

Please fill out the below form to
download the creep verification handout

Read all