In March 2020, we hosted a webinar, “Case Study : Construction Stage Analysis of Precast Bridge" by Saathwik Vudayagiri, Structural Engineer, BECA.
AS5100 In-Service Stage Analysis midas Civil Launch Geometry Construction Stage Case Study Precast Concrete Bridges Incremental Launching Method Temporary Works Launching Stage Analysis Launched Box Girder Bridge
This case study covers the following aspects:
midas Civil Prestressed Concrete Construction Stage Tips & Tutorials Precast Concrete Bridges Structural Analysis midas Civil Interface Time Dependent Losses Software Calculations Elastic Shortening
Prestress does not remain constant with time. Prestress loss is nothing but the reduction of initial applied prestress loss to an effective value. Loss of prestressing affects the strength of members and also significantly affects the member’s serviceability. Prestress loss is classified into two types:
Bridge Insight Precast Concrete Bridges Bridge Modeling Nebraska University Girder Prestressed Concrete I Girder Bridge Bulb Tee Girder Super Girder Trends of PSC I Girder AASHTO FHWA
Currently, Prestressed Concrete Beam Bridge, which is generally applied as the most economical bridge type for small and medium-sized bridges in construction works such as highways and national highways, has been introduced to the entire bridge construction field for almost 60 years after the technical proposal.
In this post, we will look at the initial development story and trends of the Prestressed Concrete girder.
Prestressed Concrete Bridge Insight Precast Concrete Bridges Prestress Tendon Profile Arrangement PSC Girder Design FEM Analysis Linear Transformation Concordant Arrangement Tensile Stress
Prestressed concrete is ‘concrete that has been given strength by artificially determining the distribution and size of the stress in advance so that the stress caused by external forces can be offset to a predetermined limit.' Prestress means ‘stress that has been artificially applied to concrete in advance to offset the tensile stresses caused by external forces.
If this definition is interpreted backward, it can be interpreted as when tensile stress caused by external forces exceeds certain stress (allowable stress or cracking stress), it can be compensated by applying the prestress accordingly. Here, the tensile stress due to external forces can be thought of as a function of:
①external force, ②geometrical shape (span of structure, boundary condition, etc), and ③ stiffness (materials properties x constant of planned section). If the external forces and the geometries (as planned by the designer) are considered to be given conditions, ‘the tensile stress due to external forces’ can be seen as a function of stiffness, and the prestress to offset the tensile stress also becomes a function of stiffness. In other words, as the cross-section of the structure becomes larger, the prestress needed becomes smaller or unnecessary. If the cross-section of the structure becomes smaller, the prestress needed becomes larger.
As prestress increases, a large number of Tendons (Tendon: components consisting of PT anchorages + tendon + ducts) are required, thereby increasing costs. Therefore, the most important condition that must be considered for tendon arrangement is selecting the most optimal cross-section considering economic feasibility.
If the schematic cross-section of the structure has been determined through historical documents and case studies, the tendons should be arranged based on their stiffness. The following two theories are contents that designers must be familiar with for efficient tendon arrangement.
The linear transformation of a tendon profile can be defined as the tendon placed on the statically indeterminate structure that rotates around one end without changing its shape within the span; the total bending moment (summation of sectional forces) is the same, but the reaction forces change.
1. If the continuous span is divided into single spans, and the vertical distance from the midpoint of the straight line connecting both ends of the tendons of every single span is the same, the Equivalent distributed force acting on the structure in terms of the load balancing concept becomes the same. However, since the equivalent end force acting on the end of every single span is different depending on the tendon profile arrangement, the moment (primary sectional force) and the deformed shape of every single span differ from each other.
2. If tendons are arranged using linear transformation so that the cross-sectional tendon profile angle (interval angle) of the central point connecting the single-span is 0˚, no additional reaction forces (the cause of secondary sectional forces) occur under boundary conditions, and the moment of every single span becomes the total moment (primary sectional force) of the continuous span.
3. If the linear transformation of the tendon profile arrangement is different from 2) and the cross-sectional tendon profile angle (interval angle) is not 0˚, an additional reaction force (the cause of secondary sectional forces) occurs under boundary conditions to make the tendon profile angle 0˚, where the deformation is equal to 2). Therefore the total moment of the continuous span (Summation of sectional forces) becomes equal to 2).
If the above contents are analyzed using FEM, the results are as shown in the table below.
If the tendon profile is arranged using linear transformation so that the tendon profile angle of the central point is 0˚, as shown in 2) above, no additional reactions will occur under the boundary conditions. This arrangement will be the same as the pressure line (C-line, please refer to relevant PSC books) calculated from the location of the compression force (calculated by considering only the prestress) of the cross-sectional force at each location. In other words, the pressure line is determined by the tendon arrangement profile, and if the tendon profile undergoes linear transformation, the pressure line does not change. When the arrangement of the tendon profile is in the same manner as the pressure line, it is referred to as the concordant arrangement.
This arrangement gives an advantage to the concordant arrangement for statically indeterminate structures since the summation sectional forces are the same and no additional secondary reactions occur (mostly harmful to structures). If the designer intends to arrange the tendon profile similarly to the concordant arrangement, the initially assumed tendon profile arrangement will require a process of determining the pressure line and alignment of the pressure line by linear transformation is necessary, which will inevitably lead to several trials and errors. Therefore, it is necessary to adjust the pressure line so that it does not deviate outside the cross-sectional area by properly assuming the initially assumed tendon arrangement (including the stiffness and tendon volume of the structure) through past experiences or examples.
The PSC girder design process (Tendon arrangement process) can be classified into four stages: ① model/construction method and section selection, ② satisfactory stress limits, ③ satisfactory deflection limits, ④ satisfactory strength limits.
As mentioned in Chapter 1, the prestress (which can be seen as the tendon amount) can be seen as a function of ① external forces, ② geometric shape, and ③ stiffness. External forces (mainly specified in the design criteria of each task) and the geometric shape should be considered when selecting the appropriate PSC girder type/construction method and section (which can be seen as ③ stiffness). Detailed comments on this will not be covered because they do not correspond to the purpose of this article, but as an example, please take a look at the table showing previously investigated FCM PSC Box girders.
It should not be forgotten that the type/construction of PSC girders and the selection of sections determine the stiffness, which is the primary condition for the designer to perform first for tendon arrangement.
B. Satisfactory stress limits
The design standards (mainly road bridge design standards) for each task stipulate the external forces (loads) to be considered during design and the allowable stress of the tension and concrete member. Accordingly, the tendons shall be arranged to satisfy allowable stresses of tensile and concrete materials. At this time, at least two of the following construction steps must be considered.
As shown in the table above, the concrete stresses that the initial and final stages of construction must satisfy are opposite to each other.
The initial/maximum prestress force (Pi) and the final/minimum prestress force (Pf) of the tension member can be calculated using the following equation described in the figure below.
Here, e: Distance from the center to the tendon’s center.
: Maximum upward eccentricity in sections that only receive compressive stress
: Maximum downward eccentricity in sections that only receive compressive stress
Using the above equation, the tendon arrangement profile can be calculated through the following order.
a. The FEM analysis calculates the initial/minimum moment (Mmin) and final/maximum moment (Mmax), due to external forces, by applying the selected cross-sectional shapes and the completed geometrical shapes.
b. Using the table below, the initial/maximum prestress force (Pi) and the final/maximum prestress force (Pf) of the tension member is calculated. Furthermore, the type of anchorage (number of strands) and the number of tendons are determined.
c. Using the distribution of the initial/minimum moments (Mmin) and the final/maximum moments (Mmax) determined by the tendons and external forces, emax and emin of several positions are determined to calculate the possible tendon arrangement area as shown in Figure 3.
d. Determine the tendon arrangement to be within the tendon arrangement area. Here, the starting and ending points of the PSC girder coincide with the center of the cross-section, and the eccentricity is maximized at the center and intermediate points of the span.
e. Calculate the pressure lines at several critical locations and modify the tendon arrangement using linear transformation to resemble the concordant arrangement.
f. Modify the tendon arrangement so that it has a smooth curve (mainly a circular curve) at the top of the midpoint
Depending on the girder longitudinal moment distribution, additional tendon arrangements may be required in some sections. In this case, it is desirable to arrange them similar to the previously calculated tendon arrangements.
From personal experience, it is more practical to refer to existing data, such as historical data or designers’ design experiences, because tendon arrangements at each task in the ideal order above can be time-consuming and inefficient. However, it cannot be overlooked that it is a prerequisite that designers must understand the ideal method of tendon arrangement.
PSC girders with tendons arrangement in accordance with the ‘satisfactory stress limits’ should be considered to meet deflection limits to ensure serviceability in accordance with design standards. Deflection limits due to live loads and impact loads are initially considered in the ‘type/construction method and section selection’. On the other hand, the deflection of the dead load+prestress applied is eliminated by the camber (improvement), which is independent of this deflection limit.
It shall be examined whether the section in which the tendon is arranged is placed in accordance with the “satisfactory stress limit” ensures safety (design strength > ultimate strength) in ultimate extreme conditions (failure state) according to design standards. In most cases, the strength limit is often satisfied when the tendon is arranged to satisfy the stress limit.
In Chapter 1, we looked at the basic conditions of tendon profile arrangement, and in Chapter 2, we looked at the theory applied to tendon profile arrangement. Lastly, Chapter 3 summarizes the tendon profile arrangement process.
The prestress introduced into the PSC girders is determined by tensile stress due to external forces and the tensile stress is determined by ① external forces, ② geometrical shape (span of structure, boundary conditions, etc), and ③ stiffness (materials properties x constant of planned section). Since the tendon arrangement is based according to its tensile stresses, it can be said that it is determined by the three conditions above. Therefore, the process of determining the arrangement of tendons is important, but we would like to remind you that the type/construction method of the PSC girders and the selection of sections suitable for external forces and geometric shapes are more important
Bridge Insight Precast Concrete Bridges Girder Span Bridge Cable Stayed Bridges Shibanpo Yangtze Bridge Stolma Bridge Raftsundet Bridge Sundoy Bridge Beipanjiang Shuipan Bridge Sandsfjord Bridge 2nd Humen Bridge 2nd Sutong Bridge Honghe Bridge Gateway Bridge
Prestressed concrete is a structural material that allows for predetermined engineering stresses to be placed in members to counteract the stresses of loads. It combines the high-strength compressive properties of concrete with the high tensile strength of steel. These prestressed concrete girder bridges are currently used in bridge construction all over the world. Research on materials and superstructures of bridges has shown that prestressed concrete girder bridges have the longest life span and require less maintenance than other bridges. Furthermore, these bridges are increasingly being used due to their aesthetic versatility, strength, quality, and reduced construction time.
midas Civil Load Rating Case Study Finite Element Analysis Precast Concrete Bridges Structural Analysis Construction Stage Analysis AASHTO Prestressed Precast Concrete Prestressing Forces Post-Tensioned Girder Bridges PPC Finite Element Modeling
PSC Bridge CS454 Bridge Assessment Tips & Tutorials Precast Concrete Bridges Moving Load Moving Load Analysis All Model 1 All Model 2 Live Loads
This 1-hour course will cover the moving load analysis and assessment design of a PSC girder bridge. Attendees will get many valuable tips on the common assessment design process of PSC bridges as per CS454.
In midas Civil 2020 v2.1, PSC bridge assessment as per CS454 has been newly implemented. During the online session, moving load analysis with All Model 2 and special vehicles will be demonstrated. Using the analysis results, assessment load effects and assessment resistances will be obtained, and they will be verified using adequacy factor and reserve factor. Ultimate limit state (flexure, shear, and torsion) and service limit state verification are provided in the tabular format and MS excel report.
midas Civil Material Properties Bridge Insight Precast Concrete Bridges Prestressed Tendon Loss Structural Analysis Structural Modeling Theoretical Results Software Results Tendon Losses
With the advent of the IT era in the 21st century, information that was previously unavailable in the engineering market has become possible. Engineering simulation using a computer program is one of them, and it is currently used in most engineering industries.
midas Civil Bridge Design Case Study Precast Concrete Bridges Bridge Wizard Girder Span Bridge Composite Girder Structural Analysis Design Consideration Traffic Loads Prestressed Composite Section
A girder bridge is one of the most common types of bridge design. Prestressing a composite girder in the negative moment region increases its stiffness by preventing cracking of concrete under service loads. In this webinar, we share the design practices of girder span bridges in Sarawak and show which functions of midas Civil can be utilized for the effective modeling of this type of structure.